When Is the Right Time to Update Your Will? Signs Your Estate Plan Needs a Second Look

An estate plan is not something you put in place once and never think about again. For families across Western New York, keeping documents current is just as important as having them in the first place.

Most people feel a genuine sense of relief after completing their estate planning documents. The will is signed, the power of attorney is in place, and the health care proxy names the right person. That relief is well-earned — getting a plan in place is a meaningful accomplishment. But it can also create a false sense of security if it leads people to believe the work is finished for good.

Estate planning documents reflect your life as it exists at the moment they are created. When your life changes — and it will — those documents may no longer say what you intend. At Klafehn, Heise & Johnson P.L.L.C., we regularly work with families who are surprised to discover that documents they signed years ago no longer fit their current situation. Here is how to recognize when it is time for a review.

Your Family Structure Has Changed

Family changes are the most common reason an estate plan needs updating — and they are easy to overlook in the moment because life moves quickly.

Marriage or Remarriage

Getting married changes your legal and financial picture significantly. In New York, marriage does not automatically revoke a prior will, which means a will created before your marriage may not adequately provide for your new spouse. Remarriage introduces additional complexity, particularly when children from a prior relationship are involved. Balancing the interests of a current spouse with those of children from a previous marriage requires careful planning — and documents that were created before the remarriage almost certainly do not reflect that balance.

Divorce

New York law does revoke certain provisions in favor of a former spouse after a divorce is finalized, but it does not rewrite your estate plan for you. Named beneficiaries on retirement accounts and life insurance policies are governed by those accounts directly — not by your will — and a divorce decree does not automatically update them. After a divorce, a thorough review of all planning documents and beneficiary designations is essential.

The Birth or Adoption of a Child or Grandchild

The arrival of a new family member is one of the most joyful reasons to revisit an estate plan. If you have minor children, your will should name a trustee and a guardian to help care for the child and the assets you leave to them — and those choices deserve to be made deliberately, not left to default. As children grow into adults, the way you want assets distributed to them may also change. Grandchildren may need to be added to a plan that was created before they were born.

The Death of a Named Beneficiary, Executor, or Agent

When someone named in your estate plan passes away — whether a beneficiary, an executor, or the agent on your power of attorney or health care proxy — that document needs to be updated promptly. A will that names a deceased beneficiary may create confusion and potential legal complications. A power of attorney that names someone who is no longer living or no longer willing to serve may leave you without the protection the document was meant to provide.

Your Financial Situation Has Changed

An estate plan that made sense when your primary assets were a modest savings account and a starter home may look very different from what is needed after decades of building a career, a business, and a family.

Significant increases in assets may warrant more sophisticated planning tools — such as trusts — that were not necessary at an earlier stage. A change in the nature of your assets, such as inheriting property or acquiring a business interest, may also require a fresh look at how your estate plan is structured. Our attorneys can help you understand whether your current wills and trusts still reflect the right approach for where you are today.

Not sure whether your current plan still fits? Reach out to our office — a review conversation is a straightforward place to start.

Your Health or a Loved One's Health Has Changed

A significant health diagnosis — for you or for someone who plays a key role in your plan — is an important reason to revisit your documents. If the person named as your health care proxy or power of attorney agent is no longer in a position to serve, or if your own health situation has changed your thinking about end-of-life care preferences, your documents should be updated to reflect that.

A health change can also bring Medicaid planning into the picture in a way that was not previously relevant. The intersection of estate planning and long-term care planning is one of the most important areas we help families navigate, and it often comes into sharper focus when a health situation changes.

You Have Moved or Your Circumstances Have Otherwise Shifted

If you have moved to New York from another state, it is worth confirming that your existing documents meet New York's legal requirements. While many states honor out-of-state wills, the specific rules around powers of attorney and health care proxies vary — and a document that worked in your previous state may not function the way you expect here.

Changes in tax law or Medicaid rules can also affect whether your current plan is still accomplishing what it was designed to do. Estate and gift tax thresholds, Medicaid eligibility rules, and asset protection strategies are all subject to change at the state and federal level, and a plan created several years ago may not account for the current legal landscape.

It Has Simply Been a Long Time

Even without a specific triggering event, a periodic review of your estate plan is a sound practice. We generally suggest that families revisit their documents every three to five years — not necessarily to make changes, but to confirm that everything still reflects their wishes and circumstances. In many cases, a review reassures you that the plan is still on track. In others, it surfaces something that deserves attention before it becomes a problem.

The families who are best positioned after a loss or a health crisis are consistently those who kept their planning current — not because they anticipated every twist in the road, but because they made it a habit to check in.

What a Review Actually Involves

A review of your estate plan does not have to be a lengthy or complicated process. It typically begins with a conversation about what has changed in your life since the documents were last signed, followed by a careful look at whether your existing documents still accomplish your goals. In some cases, minor updates are all that is needed. In others, a more substantial revision makes sense.

Either way, the goal is the same: to make sure that the people you trust have the authority they need, that your wishes are clearly documented, and that your family is not left navigating unnecessary uncertainty when they are least equipped to do so.

If it has been a few years since you last looked at your estate plan — or if something significant has changed in your life recently — we would be glad to help you take stock of where things stand. We serve individuals and families throughout Monroe, Orleans, and Genesee Counties from our offices in Brockport and Holley.

Call us at 585-637-3911 or send us a message online to schedule a time to talk.

---

Legal Disclaimer: This article provides general information about estate planning and will updates in New York State. It is not legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Individual circumstances vary, and planning strategies should be tailored accordingly. For guidance specific to your situation, please consult with the attorneys at Klafehn, Heise & Johnson P.L.L.C. Portions of this content are considered ATTORNEY ADVERTISING under the New York State Unified Court System Rules of Professional Conduct (22 NYCRR Part 1200). Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.